| Hobart | 262 | +46 | 5th |
| Nazareth | 242 | +26 | 3rd |
| Niagara | 235 | +19 | 2nd |
| Rochester | 224 | +8 | 1st |
| George Farley | 76 | +4 | |
| Anthony Sandouk | 76 | +4 | |
| Todd Jones | 79 | +7 | |
| Mike McCarthy# | 79 | +7 | |
| Mike Odai# | 79 | +7 | |
| Joe Tomasso | 79 | +7 | |
| Tom Knych | 82 | +10 | |
| Jeff Thomas | 82 | +10 |
| St. John Fisher | 249 | +33 | 4th |
# Indicates individual player